School lunches, more than a meal

January 31, 2019


Noah Penasack

Many students at HBHS and across the country choose to skip the vegetables offered at the cafeteria.

School lunches are notoriously bad. Elementary school through high school students across the country ritually complain about their cafeteria lunches, and parents often have their own horror stories. Despite an almost universal displeasure with the current state of school lunches, change is laboriously slow. Publicly funded school lunch standards have been a significant political issue in Washington for some time, and the result is a system that few people are in favor of.

HBHS is like most other schools in that the cafeteria food is unpopular.“They’re not good for kids with dietary restrictions,” said Renee Franzini ‘20. “I don’t think enough school lunches are actually worth the price” said Olivia DiPrizio ‘20. HBHS student council has even considered the issue, but it proved impassable. Jennifer Given, HBHS history teacher notes that it is a multifaceted issue. “The first component is finding funding to make up the difference for free and reduced lunch, because free and reduced lunch has all kinds of federal requirements for nutrition, and if you can find the funding for [that], then you need money to upgrade the kitchen facilities — and the upgrade would have required a bond,” said Given.

Regulations from the federal level play a significant role. In 2010, President Obama passed the Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act, which increased funding for school lunch subsidies and introduced new requirements on fats, calories, fruits and vegetables in school meals. The bill saw initial support, and coincided with First Lady Michelle Obama’s Let’s Move program. However, problems emerged. Although actual consumption of fruits and vegetables has seemed to increase, evidence suggested that kids are throwing away some of these federally mandated fruits and veggies.

Additionally, research suggests that sugar, not fat, is the real problem in American diets. For example, one study found that over 30 years, switching 5% of calorie intake from saturated fat to monounsaturated led to a 27% decrease in death — of any kind. However, not all fats are bad, according to, fats are “essential to give your body energy.”

In December, the Trump administration rolled back some of these Obama era guidelines. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) relaxed requirements for whole grains, and allowed more flavored milks and sodium. However, this too appears to be more of a political move, and is highly unlikely to fix the problem.

America as a whole has an increasingly unhealthy relationship to food. The Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that the US obesity rate is close to 40%, and costs $147 billion annually in medical bills. Heart disease, which has been linked to obesity, is the leading cause of death in the United States. Compared to other countries, the US eats the most fast food as well.

School lunches are also very important for low income children. For many of the 30 million children that receive reduced lunch, it is a major source of nutrition. When school is out, these children may not have enough to eat. When the government and schools plan what they are going to serve, it is important that they consider that school lunch may be the most nutrition a kid gets all day.

School lunches, like everything else in school, has a great capacity to shape the habits of children. If the US is serious about tackling obesity, it has to start with the youngest generation. The harsh rules that the federal government places on cafeterias are not helping. Part of the school curriculum needs to be learning a healthy relationship to food, balancing taste and nutrition. Kids eat the “healthy food” at school, and are turned off to it, averting them from future good choices.

View Comments (2)

The CavChron • Copyright 2023 • FLEX WordPress Theme by SNOLog in


Comments (2)

The CavChron LINE intends for this area to be used to foster healthy, thought-provoking discussion. Comments are expected to adhere to our standards and to be respectful and constructive. As such, we do not permit the use of profanity, foul language, personal attacks, or the use of language that might be interpreted as libelous. Comments are reviewed and must be approved by a moderator to ensure that they meet these standards. The CavChron LINE does not allow anonymous comments, and The CavChron LINE requires a valid email address. The email address will not be displayed but will be used to confirm your comments.
All The CavChron Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • L

    LUCINDAMay 22, 2020 at 4:37 am

    I work in School Nutrition I am a Food Service Assistant in a Elementary School I enjoy what I do so I take pride in my work. Reading that school lunches are not appealing to the students saddens me. I have worked for 7 years in School Nutrition I’ve worked with Middle School and Elementary Schools I haven’t had the opportunity to work with High School students but from watching the students eating habits and personally preparing meals I know the meals are nutritious and healthy and planned according to the Federal and State guidelines . It’s true that some students waste meals but many appreciate their meals and eat them and ask for second servings but aren’t allowed if the are free meals but if they can pay for an extra entree they can . I feel that the politicians don’t really understand what the children want and what is needed for their meal programs it very difficult to order meals to meet the daily requirements for their nutritional allowance some of the meals include foods that they aren’t seeing prepared at home or that they have no knowledge of so we as workers have to introduce the foods to them by getting them to at least taste it and they have choices we don’t just place foods on their trays . Unlike when I was in school times have changed in the serving of meals all students choose their foods to eat as long as it is a complete meal meaning vegetable and fruit are a must milk isn’t so the choice is their. The meals are more appealing now they including new food items such as fish nuggets , chicken fliets sandwiches , sweet potato fries and baked potatoes fresh vegetables such as kale and squash even fresh fruit strawberries , blueberries . Why kids don’t always find their appealing or tasteful is some students bring in outside foods and eat it before eating their meal I have witnessed students with big bags of chips and candy sometimes soda too and if they can’t eat it class they eat it for lunch this will make them waste a meal .In my experience with school nutrition they test each recipe before presenting it to the students so that it will be interested in eating it. The cost is really a great price for a balanced meal compared to eating in a restaurant or deli. I LOVE SCHOOL NUTRITION and I hope that one day we can get the school kitchen more improved with updated tools and equipment.

    • H

      Hannah RisemanMay 27, 2020 at 11:59 am

      Thank you for your commitment to providing students with healthy lunches and for your comment. In the future, if another student chooses to write an updated article about school lunch, may we contact you for an interview?